Few software companies matter to global trade the way SAP does.
Its platforms underpin the supply chains, manufacturing operations and finance functions of many of the world’s largest organisations. As Europe’s only Fortune 50 platform company, SAP is far more than another software vendor. It is a strategic pillar of the European economy.
Having spent years working inside SAP before moving into consulting, I have seen first-hand both the strength of its platform and the loyalty of its customer base. That is precisely why I have always believed the maintenance model deserved greater customer empathy. The all-or-nothing support model, initial terms that restarted with every additional licence purchase, and reinstatement fees that made leaving prohibitively expensive. Whether commercially justified or not, these mechanisms were designed to retain customers through contractual dependency rather than product value.
That has now changed.
On 9 July 2026, the European Commission made SAP’s commitments legally binding under EU antitrust rules, closing case AT.40823 without a finding of infringement or financial penalty. The commitments remain in force for ten years and apply globally to all existing and future SAP on-premise customers.
This is one of the most significant changes to SAP licensing and maintenance in decades.
What actually changed
Five commitments reshape the relationship between SAP and its customers.
1. The all-or-nothing maintenance model is over. Customers can now split their SAP landscape into separate commercial installations, each with its own maintenance provider, its own support level, or no maintenance at all, without triggering re-discounting or mandatory licence purchases. Supporting the digital core with SAP while using third-party support for satellite systems is now a contractual right rather than a commercial negotiation.
2. Maintenance terms no longer restart. Purchasing additional licences no longer resets the initial maintenance period. For many customers, every incremental purchase quietly extended the contractual lock-in. That mechanism has now disappeared.
3. Shelfware finally has an exit path. For contracts above EUR 500K, underutilised licences identified during audits can reduce the maintenance base through a structured mechanism, capped at 20 percent per year. Customers now have a defined path to unwind excess maintenance rather than carrying unused licences indefinitely.
4. New termination rights. Customers can terminate maintenance without re-discounting in cases of product end-of-life, failed implementations, insolvency, divestitures, or workforce reductions exceeding 10 percent over two years. These rights apply retroactively from January 2025.
5. Returning is no longer punished. Perhaps the most overlooked change. Reinstatement fees are abolished entirely, and back-maintenance is capped at the lower of 50 percent of the off-support fees or six months’ payments. Leaving SAP support is no longer a one-way door.
The enforcement mechanism is equally significant. Should SAP fail to honour these commitments, the Commission can impose fines of up to 10 percent of SAP’s worldwide annual turnover, with compliance monitored by an independent trustee.
Why this is actually good news for SAP
At first glance, this appears to weaken SAP’s commercial position. Around a large group organisations still operate SAP ECC, and many now have greater freedom to use third-party maintenance while determining their S/4HANA strategy on their own timeline rather than SAP’s.
That interpretation is understandable. I also believe it misses the bigger picture.
This gives SAP the opportunity to compete on value instead of contractual dependency.
The maintenance model generated predictable revenue, but it also created friction and, in many cases, eroded trust. And trust, not lock-in, is ultimately what drives customers to invest in SAP for their future transformation platform. A customer who remains because leaving is expensive is not truly loyal. A customer who chooses to stay because the product, the innovation and the partnership justify the investment is.
Ironically, these commitments may strengthen SAP’s competitive position over the long term. Customers who move to providers such as Rimini Street or Spinnaker remain recoverable because the reinstatement barriers have disappeared. Customers can retain SAP support for their strategic digital core while sourcing alternatives elsewhere, allowing SAP to keep demonstrating value where it matters most. Freedom to leave often becomes one of the strongest reasons to stay.
The broader industry message
The Commission described these commitments as a benchmark for the wider software industry and explicitly referenced similar practices in cloud markets. That should attract attention well beyond Walldorf. Every enterprise software provider relying on contractual friction rather than customer value should take notice.
What On-Premise Customers should do now
Three immediate actions stand out.
Review your maintenance agreements alongside SAP Note 3776551 and understand which new contractual rights apply.
Reassess your shelfware position, as the single-metric mechanism materially changes maintenance economics.
Revisit any transformation business case that assumed SAP maintenance which were locked into any cloud extension policy , because that fundamentally shifted.
The real test starts now
The proof is not what appears in the Commission’s decision.But it is how these principles show up in renewal contracts, order forms and commercial negotiations over the coming years. That is where the independent trustee will earn its keep.
I remain optimistic. If SAP implements these commitments consistently, transparently and in the spirit in which they were agreed, it has the opportunity to rebuild something no contractual clause could ever guarantee: trust.
And trust, not lock-in, is what will keep SAP where it belongs, as a critical growth engine for global trade.
John Stenby has spent his career at the intersection of strategy, technology and entrepreneurship, helping some of Denmark’s largest companies turn IT and SAP into real business outcomes rather than just IT projects. From owning the full executive relationship, to co-founding and scaling The Tech Collective, and now shaping Deloitte’s SAP GTM in Denmark, he loves building something new – setting a bold direction together and then doing the hard work to make the transformation happen in practice.?
This opinion was first published on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/eu-just-rewrote-saps-maintenance-playbook-sap-should-say-john-stenby-svnle/